Showing posts with label faith. Show all posts
Showing posts with label faith. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Doctors Who Write

Last week I read the following poem, by Warner V. Slack, M.D., on the blog kept by Paul Levy, President and CEO of Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. Dr. Slack kindly gave me permission to share it here. It's arresting, inspiring, and profound. I am grateful for writers (and doctors) like him, who stop and think, and who make the effort to see, the first task of any artist (or physician).


ENCOUNTER ON THE STAIRS
By Warner V. Slack, MD

Next to Children’s Hospital, in a hurry
Down the stairs, two at a time
Slowed down by a family, moving slowly
Blocking the stairway, I’m in a hurry
I stop, annoyed, I’m in a hurry
Seeing me, they move to the side
A woman says softly, “sorry” in Spanish
I look down in passing, there’s a little boy
Unsteady in gait, holding onto an arm
Head shaved, stitches in scalp
Patch over eye, thin and pale
He catches my eye and gives me a smile
My walk is slower for the rest of the day


***


One of my most sacred "academic" values is a reverence for story and language. As in the case of being a "person of faith," being a person with a deep love of the arts and humanities can sometimes be marginalizing in the medical world. Medical training, in fact, can be a desert for those who thirst for really good writing, as a Time article once affirmed, so when I find a poet like Dr. Slack, I feel like someone who has taken a long-awaited cold drink of water on a scorching day, or who has found a breezy spot under shade trees in an otherwise arid landscape.

I especially admire those who can write poetry. Of all literary forms, I think this distilled form is the most challenging - all that meaning to cram into an itty bitty space! Not a word out of place! Next hardest, I think, is the short story, also a distillation of meaning without the wider "wiggle room" afforded by novellas and novels.

I found this wonderful paragraph by Stephen J. Dubner on the subject of doctors who write:

"So why do these doctors write so well, and so much better (to my mind, at least) than other non-writers? Perhaps there are elements of doctoring that lie in harmony with writing: peeling back the layers to get to the core of an issue; confronting the obvious but being willing to look beyond it; learning where to 'cut in,' of course; and, more than anything, recognizing that this object before you – in one case a human body, in the other a manuscript – is on a certain level a miraculous object with the power to astound, and on another level is a complex, dynamic system which can (and must be) reduced to a schematic, laid out on paper or x-ray film."

We learn as medical students that the most important resource for our healing efforts is a thorough history of our patient. Story, story, story: it's not only what makes us human, but also what drives us and helps us excel at our humanity. I thank Dr. Slack, and his intellectual / artistic / spiritual ancestors and colleagues: Anton Chekhov, William Carlos Williams, W. Somerset Maugham, A. Conan Doyle, A.J. Cronin, Walker Percy, Ethan Canin, Sid Schwab, and so many other doctors who write (or writers who doc!), for their gifts, and their balm.

Friday, August 31, 2007

"We Can't All Be Mother Teresa" - Or Can We?


The recent publicity about Mother Teresa: Come Be My Light, the soon-to-be published journals and letters of Blessed Teresa of Calcutta, surprised me. One author called the revelations of her profound doubt and sense of God's absence "stunning," but I am not stunned at all, except to learn that others are stunned. I am surprised, not only by the surprise of others, but also by the complete lack of understanding some people appear to have about spiritual struggle. Is it so impossible to imagine that people for whom spirituality consists of deep, intimate relationship will struggle with that relationship?

Jacob wrestled with God. John of the Cross wrote about his "dark night of the soul." Many truly holy people who actually bother to WORK on their spirituality find that the work can be hard, painful, dark, and daunting, that their faith can waver to the point of buckling.

I think this is especially true among humanitarian workers, who have to gaze upon the face of the Suffering Christ on a daily basis. Whether or not you believe God exists, that Face certainly does, and it hurts to see it, live with it, try to make it better.

I've read that some have reacted with disdain to Mother Teresa's inner battles, suggesting she was hypocritical to profess a faith that, in reality, eluded her. First of all, I think anyone who has lived a life as generous as hers can feel free to cast stones - after all, you've been in the trenches; you know what it's like - but everyone else can shut up! Secondly, what a total misunderstanding of the nature of a life in faith. Doubt and near-despair are part of the process of, and perhaps essential to, becoming a fully integrated human being - integrated, whole, holy. The words of Madeleine L'Engle are worth revisiting: "Those who believe they believe in God but without passion in the heart, without anguish of mind, without uncertainty, without doubt, and even at times without despair, believe only in the idea of God, and not in God himself."

I get annoyed when people of one faith - and I include atheism as a faith, as I would any other system of thought centered around something that cannot be revealed by proof - gloat over perceived deficiencies of another. The childish arrogance of being absolutely certain and of believing oneself to be incontrovertibly right, and the cloying superiority with which the "right" people criticize the people they believe to be "wrong," are divisive, unproductive, and morally inferior means by which to "edify" society. The irony of any glee detractors might have over Mother Teresa's faith crises lies in the fact that her humility and human pain actually have a greater power to teach and reach others, who might be going through some spiritual striving of their own.

A Time article points out, "Teresa found ways, starting in the early 1960s, to live with [darkness within faith] and abandoned neither her belief nor her work." I think this is the true meaning of holiness or sainthood, right here. It's what Harper Lee described in To Kill a Mockingbird as the meaning of courage: going on despite obstacles, lack of support, the risk of defeat, and near-total loss of hope. If Mother Teresa made mistakes, had imperfections, and lost faith time and again, what right does any one of us have to criticize, resent, or judge that, or claim she is a less holy person because of her struggles? Can any of us claim we know and understand what lies in the depths of anyone else's heart? I think these journals and letters are the closest we are going to get, and if they reveal a person who experienced unspeakable loneliness and pain but tried her best anyway to live a loving life, then we could learn something from her - about our humanity, our spirit, ourselves. Such an individual is just what our church might declare, in a spirit of hope, to be a saint: not a perfect person, but one who poured herself out completely, in yearning and in hard work, to reach the perfection of love to which every human being is called.

Thursday, August 16, 2007

à la Recherche de Saint René

We started our day yesterday at a lovely outdoor mass in Montreuil-sur-Maine, on the banks of the Mayenne river, at a place known as La Grotte, meant to be a replica of the grotto of Massabielle in Lourdes. The gospel reading was the passage containing the Magnificat, probably more beautiful in French than in most languages:


Mon âme exalte le Seigneur, mon esprit exulte en Dieu mon Sauveur. Il s'est penché sur son humble servante; désormais tous les âges me diront bienheureuse. Le Puissant fit pour moi des merveilles; Saint est son nom!

All the towns we drove through appeared abandoned - shut down for the Feast Day of the Assumption of Mary. It was like driving through a U.S. town on Thanksgiving Day or Christmas morning. Restaurants were open, though, and we were able to enjoy a delicious lunch of prosciutto with melon and spinach cannelloni at La Fleur du Maquis just outside Saint-Martin-du-Bois.



After lunch we drove into Saint-Martin to see if we could get a look at the baptismal font in the church where René Goupil, patron saint of anesthetists, had been baptized on May 15, 1608. To our great surprise, despite the fact that there was not a soul visible on the streets (I did see a little girl poke her head out the door of a café called, fortuitously, Le Goupil), the church door was ajar as if waiting for us to enter (the mairie, on the other hand, was locked). There was no one around. At the back of the church we found a plaque commemorating René's baptism as well the 400-year-old baptismal font beneath it. This had at one time been in a park outside a restaurant in Angers, according to the book A Ghost in the Mohawk Valley by William Breault, S.J., but comparing pictures of it there and our own pictures from the church yesterday confirmed that it had been transported back to its original place in Saint-Martin-du-Bois.



After this satisfying visit we made our way back to the Chateau du Plessis via the village of La Jaille-Yvon, which is up on a hill and has a 12th-century church as well as a breathtaking view of the rolling countryside below. Dinner was another gourmet masterpiece from Valerie, a terrine or little charlotte of fromage de chevre with chives and a salmon purée, with a sweet cherry tomato on top, followed by a succulent quail in a coq au vin type of sauce with the tiniest little onions I have ever seen. Dessert was a dense chocolate fondant with orange sorbet.

The best part of dinner was the after-dinner conversation, which went till midnight. Among the eight of us there were six countries represented (Romania, England, Ireland, Denmark, the U.S., and the Philippines). A couple from Manchester, England, who were Seventh Day Adventists; the Englishman's Anglican parents; a couple from Ireland who were atheist humanists; and my husband and I, fairly moderate Catholics, all got into a spirited and good-humored discussion about faith. From this lively, intellectually stimulating, and enjoyable conversation I relearned about myself that my journey in faith has been largely one of hope rather than arrogant certainty, and that if I believe anything, it's that it's just as erroneous to believe in God because good things happen as it is to disbelieve in God because bad things happen. The question is, how does each person's faith take the path it takes, and why?


***




This morning we contacted the cattle farmer who owns Le Grand Oncheray to see if we could visit the place. Le Grand Oncheray was discovered to be René's home relatively recently, in the 1970's. We had made contact with the owner through the mairie in Saint-Martin-du-Bois a couple of times before and explained my interest in visiting René's place of birth. He was a shy and taciturn but gracious man who met us at the farm and, over an hour or so of conversation while we were there, warmed gradually, especially after his girlfriend, an equally gracious woman, arrived. He showed us a plaque he had made himself to commemorate the homestead's history as René's family home, now a rather ramshackle but still charming farmhouse. He also pulled out a folder of articles about the place written by various people with an interest in René Goupil. We were thankful for his willingness to welcome strangers from the U.S. on an unusual mission to track down a fairly obscure and rather elusive saint.


Valerie's husband's property was right next door, and we had been given leave to drive in and see it. This chateau, too, was a gorgeous one, and a tenant on the property had reindeer, a yurt, and a large, very affectionate camel who enchanted our children. After this pleasant stop we drove through Saint-Martin-du-Bois with a mind to pick up a picnic lunch in Segré, just beyond, but before continuing on I asked my husband to stop to see if we could sneak a peek at the ancient baptismal records which, I had read in Breault's book, could be found in the mairie. The mairie doors were locked, still on holiday from yesterday, but through a wide open window we saw two women inside discussing something.

"Excuse me, is the mairie open today?" my husband asked in French.

"No, we're closed, but do you need something?" came the reply.

"Well...we're retracing the footsteps of Saint René, on a pilgrimage of sorts, and we heard his baptismal registry could be found here..."

"Ah, oui! Bien sûr!" said one of the women. "Come, we'll open the door back here for you...You know, you're lucky to find me here today; usually I'm not here on holidays...Now what year was it, his baptism? 1608? Hmm..." She opened a closet door in the office. "Let's see...1800's...1700's...ah, here we are, 1575 to 1630's."

We leafed carefully through the slim, bound volume with its beautifully penned record in old French, came across his older brother Claude's bapistmal record from 1607, our excitement mounting, then finally found his, at the bottom of a page, faded but still legible. The lovely woman made an enlarged photocopy of it for us to take home. When we left the mairie, out of curiosity I crossed the street to the church to see if it was open. This time it was locked.


We got our picnic lunch and spent the early part of the afternoon at a place called Le Domaine de la Petite Couère, a large estate where various animals such as alpacas, watusi, black swans, emus, mountain goats, pigs, cattle, and water fowl are kept. There is also a period "village" containing a blacksmith's shop, saboterie, school room, general store with artifacts from the 19th and early 20th centuries, replicas of cottages and depictions of village life, and collections of old tools, vehicles, costumes, toys, and the like. Here and there there were witty literary quotes tacked up to the walls, which were entertaining. The place reminded me of the Shelburne Museum in Vermont or the Adirondack Museum, but smaller in scale, and very interesting.

After this we headed home, a three-hour drive. I have been very impressed with the French highway and road system. We have managed to find every town without a map, simply because directions are so well-marked on the road. Essentially all we had to do was find our way from one church steeple to another. There have been a couple of more humorous reminders that we are in France: the roadside coffee shops serve quiche and crêpes, and even the toll collectors look like fashion models. Vive la France!

We're now back at La Morinière after a fruitful pilgrimage in the steps of Saint René. Making the journey, even in reverse - from his place of death to his place of birth, over the last couple of months - has given us an idea of the scale of this journey, especially when one considers what was available to travelers (or not) in the 1630's. He had to leave Anjou, a region which reminds me so much of the Champlain Valley in Vermont and the Mohawk Valley in New York, where he died. I had to wonder the other night, while driving down, if it had been similar back then, too, in the 1600's, and if being in New France had made him homesick for the landscape of his birthplace. He traveled overland probably to Paris and then to Dieppe, then boarded a ship bound for the New World, then somehow managed within a couple of years to get from Quebec to what is now Auriesville, NY, only to die there after weeks of torture. His brief life was a pilgrimage in and of itself, with a long, lonely trek in its final years. I can't explain why his life means such a great deal to me, but I'm glad to have traced its outline, knowing of course that we'll probably never be able to describe fully its depth and its meaning.


Sunday, August 5, 2007

The Power of Books

HAPPY BIRTHDAY, DAD!

Is it just me, or are dads sort of challenging to find birthday presents for? :)

I have a tiny little present here, in the form of a link (Dad, click on the word link) to a fascinating timeline entitled "The History of the Book in the Philippines."

Some highlights that caught my eye:

In 1531, Queen Isabella forbade the transport of secular or fiction books into the Spanish colonies. What, no fiction?! No fun!

In 1583 the Inquisition authorized the Bishop of Manila (or his "people") to inspect arriving ships for books listed in the Index of Forbidden Books, or the Index Librorum Prohibitorum. These would be confiscated. (And then what, I wonder?)

In 1610 the first Tagalog grammar was published. In 1618 and 1622 respectively, the Augustinians and the Jesuits set up printing presses. The Franciscans established one in 1692.

Just for perspective, elsewhere in the world, the King James Bible was published in 1611; the Jamestown Massacre occurred in the New World in 1622; and in 1692, the Salem Witch Trials began in Massachusetts.

***

I remember how as a child I treasured the books my parents brought back to the Philippines from abroad, and I read them over and over. Good children's books were not so easy to come by in Manila, as I recall, in the early 70's. One of my most vivid memories of our move to the U.S. in 1981 is of how astonished I was to walk into the library at my new school and see shelves from floor to ceiling completely filled with books. I had never seen so many books in my life. Something awoke in me that has never left - a sense of awe over books, a quickening of the pulse whenever I walk into a room full of them, a love of the sensual pleasure of them - the way the pages smell when I first open a book, the feeling of turning those pages, reading words and somehow having those written letters conjure up scenes and lives in my mind, as if from nothing.

With that kindling of a passion for books came a heady infatuation with words, with language and with languages. I felt I could almost taste them in my mouth. Even now, words I like make my mouth feel good, whereas those I don't seem to leave a bad taste in there, or an annoyance in the ear that induces grimacing.

***

So many memories I cherish of my parents involve literature. Every time I see a full moon shining through wisps of clouds at night I hear my father's voice quoting Noyes: "The moon was a ghostly galleon tossed upon cloudy seas." When I think of T.S. Eliot - especially since I work with patients, if not etherized, anesthetized on the table - I remember my mother opening a beautiful leather-bound volume of his poetry in a musty, second-hand book store and reading to me from Prufrock. And to this day I cannot dog-ear my pages without feeling I have betrayed my beloved grandmother, who taught me to treat books with love and reverence.

***

If I were to chorerograph a ballet depicting the story of the Garden of Eden, I wouldn't use fruit or sexual license to represent the mythic "Forbidden Fruit." I would have the Serpent character pluck a book off a shelf (or a tree) and hand it to Eve and have her dance around with it for a while before sharing it with Adam.

I can see why people would be afraid of ideas, of learning and thinking for oneself. Insight is powerful; it is power. I know from experience that knowledge and education challenge blind faith.

To that I say an emphatic Amen.

God is not God if God wants unthinking creatures to go around paying thoughtless lip-service. Why forbid the fruit, then? Did the God of Genesis know something about "Adam" and "Eve" that they didn't even realize about themselves - like, perhaps, the fact that they weren't quite ready for the responsibility? Sounds familiar - how many ethical issues has humankind dredged up and been completely ready for?

I think what happens next in the story pretty much demonstrates Adam and Eve's level of readiness, or lack thereof. I believe the "Original Sin" didn't consist of failure to obey a puppeteer god, but rather of self-interest. They grabbed at the Tree's fruit for the wrong reason. They got sucked into listening to external pressures without real knowledge of themselves first, and they wanted the fruit, not as a means to serve their world or honor others, but rather to glorify themselves.

The irony of the Serpent's temptation - You will become like God - is that that's exactly what a loving God would want: human beings so fully realized in their humanity, so spiritually adept, that divinity shines through them. Trust a "snake," though, to miss the point, to not only lack understanding but to completely misunderstand, to fail to realize that knowledge of good and evil - and perhaps, of one's own vulnerability / nakedness - is the only way to make choosing good a valid, freely-made choice.

I do not believe this story, in what many consider the Book of Books, is factual. But I do believe it is true. Because it's a story of me, and him, and her, and you.

Sunday, July 29, 2007

Would You Still Love Me If I Had No Face?


Chances are, if we were dating, and you were my boyfriend, and a pit bull or Rottweiler chewed my face off, you'd probably dump me sooner or later, even if you thought I was the most beautiful and special person you had ever known and you knew you'd never meet another person like me for the rest of your life.

Let's face it: faces are important.

Our faces identify us uniquely; so while "who we are" is not synonymous with "what we look like," people who can recognize me can point to my face, and say, "Yes, that's T."

We experience the world and the stories of our lives largely through our faces. A breathtaking mountain view, an achingly beautiful passage of music, a delectable restaurant meal, the smell of roses or chocolate or candles or wood burning in winter, a baby's head on your cheek, a lover's kiss, a laugh-so-hard-you-gotta-cry type of conversation with your best friend - all these things reach us through our faces.

We need our faces for a lot of important things. Food stays in our mouths instead of dribbling onto the table because of our facial muscles. People relate to us through our faces; our faces very often trigger our most important relationships and are instrumental in our continuing interactions. People understand us because we express ourselves with our faces as well as our voices. Our faces share our meaning, and our meaning is what we exist to communicate.

If you lost your face, in a way, you would lose your whole world.

But now surgeons can give you part of a face back. This morning the Boston Globe reported that Boston's own Dr. Bohdan Pomahac will begin to perform partial face transplants at Brigham and Women's Hospital. This is historic. There have been three other successful face transplants that I know of: two in France, one in China. A flurry of medical, ethical, and philosophical questions comes up each time the possibility of such a transplant arises.

Here's what I think would be great about restoring people's faces: the recipients could speak and eat properly again; they could participate in society once again without feeling so marginalized by their appearance; and they could remove some of the disfigurement that marred such a vital symbol of individual identity and that probably caused considerable psychological pain.

Here are the problems I have with the procedure: the recipient would have to remain on anti-rejection medications for life, which are not benign; if rejection occurred, the recipient would likely have to endure further disfguring surgery or a potentially grave illness; and the donor, as far as I understand from the case of Isabelle Dinoire, who received a partial face transplant in Amiens in November of 2005, would have to be a beating-heart donor, a situation which could be ethically problematic for some, especially those with ambivalence about the declaration of clinical death by brain death criteria.

Some people have also brought up identity issues - the psychological difficulty for donors' loved ones of having a portion of their loved one's face removed and placed on a stranger, and the challenge for the recipient of living life with an anatomically different appearance. To my mind these are outweighed by the potential medical risks to which the recipient is subjected.

Beyond these, I think this issue of face transplants calls each and every conscientious person to a reflective examination of his or her values, of what role the idea of self-acceptance should play in seeking treatment or healing for a devastating injury, and whether our criteria for accepting one another are themselves so acceptable. I don't have any answers; only questions. In fact I had a lot of tough questions swimming about in my head as I read about this stunning break-through. I've written down some of them, and while the answers may seem clear to some, I believe that clarity is contradicted by the disparity between our behavior as a society and what we say we believe or hold dear:

Why is having a mauled face so much worse than having a mauled limb, which itself can be physically and emotionally agonizing?

Why might agreeing to donate part of your face be harder than agreeing to donate your own heart - is your face more "yours" than your heart?

Does a human being have to look like a human being to have worth and dignity?

Does a sick and dying human being, or a malformed human being, or an "incomplete" human being, have less worth than other human beings? (History has shown the people can't even tolerate human beings of a different nationality or color, despite well-intentioned statements by many about the belief in every person's instrinsic value; what does that say about how we as a society assign worth?)

I have written before that the core of my faith is the belief that every person is precious. How well I live up to that faith, and how that fits in with the intricacies of the medical and sociological issues that are unfolding today, I can't say for certain. I guess I just have to keep learning as I go along.

Friday, May 18, 2007

Faith, Children, & Some Big Questions

A couple of nights ago at the end of our usual bedtime prayers my kids gave thanks "that Mommy had a good oboe lesson." Warm fuzzies! I thought this was one of the cutest moments of the week. It's so touching to receive from support from one's own kids, who have nothing additional to gain from their show of affection and give so openly from their hearts.

Last Tuesday we shared one of those "Catholic childhood moments" talking about patron saints. My daughter was laughing at the dinner table at the thought that of all the different types of doctors out there, it's anesthesiologists who have a patron saint, René Goupil, a humble, sweet Jesuit missionary & surgeon who was martyred in Canada in 1642. I could write a whole post just on my admiration for this almost-anonymous guy, whose compassion for the sick and "patience in adversity" were so awe-inspiring to his peers.

So many people misunderstand about saints. I was explaining to our kids that people often seem to confuse talking to the departed with worship of the divine. I told them we can only worship God, but if the spirits of those who have passed from this life can live on and help us by praying for us, then we can certainly TALK to any of them, be they parents or friends or canonized saints. Then of course we had to browse the internet for various professions and situations that might have their own patron saints, and as I remember feeling as a child, they seemed quite captivated by the many stories of individuals we found. My son exclaimed, half in delight, half in dismay, "But now we'll have even MORE questions!" Last night my son continued with his exploration of the lives of the saints by reading part of Robert Kennedy's children's book on Saint Francis, which in one instance describes Francis of Assisi's kindness to lepers. Leprosy held a certain morbid fascination for my science-oriented little boy, and I was touched when he felt very sad to learn that lepers used to have to wear a bell to warn people of their coming so people could "run for their lives" in the opposite direction. I believe reading stories about people who have learned how to love better, show more kindness and compassion, and be more present to others, helps teach these values and virtues.

It's not always easy to choose faith in a world and culture in which rational empiricism is so exalted. I'm talking about the medical world, of course, though there are certainly many people of faith who work in the world of medicine. I've often struggled with this dialectical tension. Very often it seems words like "spirit" and "faith" are so highly disdained by many of my colleagues (disdain being the opposite of compassion, ironically, though compassion is supposed to be the quality that DEFINES us as a profession). If only they could answer my son's question, "But what CAUSED the Big Bang?" or explain to me why sound waves from a wooden tube stimulating cells in the cochlea and causing chain reactions of neurotransmitters in the brain can produce the transcendent experience we know as MUSIC, or solve the mystery of what life is and when it begins and ends and why. I've had to pronounce the end of life on a couple of occasions, and I struggle with it, because I know not every cell in the person's body has undergone cell death, yet I also know the person is dead. Or do I?

Most people don't realize anesthesiologists are in the business of RESUSCITATION rather than "putting to sleep." Consciousness, life, and death are always on our minds somehow or another.